Mentoring

IDPs for biomedical postdocs are required. It is strongly encouraged that all postdocs complete an IDP with the faculty mentor. Faculty mentors in the following schools are required to submit their postdocs completed IDP to The Office of Biomedical Postdoctoral Programs (BPP).

Perelman School of Medicine
PennVet
Penn Nursing
Penn Dental
School of Arts & Sciences, Biology Department

The National Academies and the National Institutes of Health (NIH) have identified IDPs as a critical component of postdoctoral training. The NIH policy states:

NIH encourages institutions to develop Individual Development Plans (IDPs) for graduate students and postdoctoral researchers (including scholars, trainees and fellows, and individuals in other postdoctoral positions) supported by NIH awards by October 2014. The IDPs should be broadly implemented for all graduate students and postdoctoral researchers supported by NIH…

[As of] Oct. 1, 2014… NIH will begin to encourage grantees to report the use of those IDPs on the progress report, regardless of the type of NIH grant that is used for support.

Although not yet a formal NIH requirement, those who don’t adopt the IDP locally now are likely to be at a disadvantage at their next competitive review. Note that this policy applies to all trainees supported by NIH funds, whether training grants, R01s or other.

Mentors’ responsibilities include: (i) developing in consultation with the postdoc a mutually satisfactory research project or scholarly program; (ii) encouraging postdocs to present their work and to publish their results in a timely fashion; (iii) encouraging postdocs to acquire and enhance their knowledge and technical skills as dictated by their current and future needs; (iv) arrangement and oversight of teaching opportunities as appropriate to their discipline and program; (v) encouraging postdocs to apply for training and research support as appropriate; (vi) meeting regularly with their postdocs to discuss progress in their research; (vii) providing an annual review of performance that includes a discussion of the individualized development plan (IDP) or equivalent performance document; (viii) ensuring that postdocs are aware of University policies regarding postdoctoral training and are instructed about research policies of the University; and (ix) providing career counseling.

It is expected that postdocs undergo a review of their performance on an annual basis. A written evaluation should be prepared and delivered to each postdoc by their faculty mentor. This is often provided through the structure of an Individual Development Plan (IDP). Criteria for such evaluations will vary according to the nature of the position and the department or center in which it is located. Goals and objectives, as well as the criteria for annual evaluations, should be communicated to the postdocs at the time of initial hire and at the start of each succeeding year. Training and professional development workshops attended should be documented within the annual evaluation.